Skip to main content

Chords & Harmony

Tone Cluster

Definition

A tone cluster is a chord of neighboring notes, each usually a whole step or half step from the next, played together. On the piano it is often played with the flat of the hand, the fist or the forearm.

A tone cluster is a chord made of notes that sit right next to each other, each usually a major or minor second from the next, sounded at the same moment. Instead of the gaps of a triad (C, skip D, E, skip F, G), a cluster fills everything in: C D E F G all at once. The result is a thick, buzzing block of sound, a strong dissonance in which you hear color and weight more than separate notes. "Tone cluster" is the usual American term; British books often just say cluster.

Three treble-clef panels in 4/4, each with one whole-note cluster. White keys: C4, D4, E4, F4, G4. Black keys: F-sharp4, G-sharp4, A-sharp4, C-sharp5, D-sharp5. Chromatic: D-sharp4, E4, F-natural4, F-sharp4, G4. The noteheads sit on both sides of the stem position because the notes are a second apart.
Left: a white-key cluster, the five white keys from C4 to G4. Middle: a black-key cluster, the five black keys from F♯4 to D♯5. Right: a chromatic cluster, all five keys from D♯4 to G4, a half step apart. Each one is written out note by note and played as a single block.

Kinds of cluster

  • White-key clusters use only white keys, a run of whole and half steps.
  • Black-key clusters use only black keys. Because the black keys are grouped in twos and threes, neighbors here are a whole step or a minor third apart.
  • Chromatic clusters take every key, white and black, between two notes, so every note is a half step from the next.

How to play one

Small clusters can be played with the fingers. Larger ones are played with the flat of the hand, the side of the fist, or the whole forearm laid along the keys. Keep the touch firm but relaxed: drop the weight of the arm into the keys and let the fleshy part of the hand or arm do the work, not the bony wrist or elbow.

Lay the flat of your hand, palm and fingers, along the white keys from C4 to B4 and press them all at once: seven neighboring notes sound together as one cluster.

How it looks on the page

Notation varies between composers. Some write out every note of the cluster, as in the figure. Henry Cowell, who wrote many cluster pieces, usually wrote only the outer notes, with a sign to say whether to play the white keys, the black keys or both. When you meet an unusual sign in modern piano music, check the performance notes at the front of the score.

A short history

The American composer Henry Cowell demonstrated forearm clusters at the keyboard in 1913, and built pieces such as The Tides of Manaunaun on them. He was not the first: František Koczwara's The Battle of Prague (about 1788) is said to ask for groups of notes played with the palm to suggest cannon fire, and Charles Ives, in his Concord Sonata, called for a length of wood to hold down a long row of keys. Béla Bartók asked Cowell's permission before making clusters the basic harmony of "The Night's Music" from Out of Doors (1926), and jazz pianists such as Cecil Taylor took them up as well. Today clusters are part of the everyday vocabulary of 20th-century and later music.

Not every chord with a second

A single second inside a voicing, as in an added-note chord or a sus2 chord, does not make a cluster. A cluster is built from neighboring keys throughout, so that no gap is left in the block.

Common questions

Who invented the tone cluster?

No single person. Earlier composers occasionally asked for groups of neighboring keys, but the American composer Henry Cowell made clusters central to his piano music from 1913 on, and he is usually credited with popularizing them.

Was this entry helpful?

Comments