Sound & Acoustics
FM Synthesis
FM synthesis makes a tone by letting one oscillator, the modulator, vary the frequency of another, the carrier, at an audio rate. This adds new frequencies, called sidebands, that can sound harmonic and bright or metallic.
Vibrato is a slow, small change of pitch. Now speed it up. When one oscillator pushes another's frequency up and down hundreds of times a second, you stop hearing a wobble: you hear a new tone with a different timbre. That is frequency modulation (FM) synthesis. The oscillator you hear is the carrier; the one doing the pushing is the modulator. John Chowning found the effect at Stanford University in 1967 while experimenting with vibrato, and he described the method in the Journal of the Audio Engineering Society in 1973.
Sidebands: where the new frequencies come from
When a sine wave modulates another sine wave, new components appear called sidebands. They lie at the carrier frequency plus and minus whole multiples of the modulator frequency: C ± M, C ± 2M, C ± 3M and so on. Two settings decide the sound:
- The ratio of carrier to modulator decides where the sidebands fall. At 1:1 they land on every harmonic of the carrier, giving a sawtooth-like series. At 1:2 they land only on the odd harmonics, a little like a square wave. A ratio that is not a simple whole-number one gives inharmonic sidebands, the metallic colors that suit bell and cymbal sounds.
- The modulation index decides how many sidebands are strong. It is how far the modulator pushes the carrier's frequency, divided by the modulator's frequency. A low index adds a couple of weak sidebands; a high index spreads energy over many, and the tone gets brighter.
Brightness that moves
Because the index controls brightness, an envelope on the modulator's level shapes the tone over time with no filter at all. A modulator envelope that starts high and decays gives a bright attack that mellows, the way many acoustic notes are brightest at their start. It does the job a filter envelope does in subtractive synthesis.
Operators and algorithms
Stanford licensed Chowning's patent to Yamaha in the 1970s, and the sounds of Yamaha's DX7 of 1983 had a strong influence on the music of the 1980s. In an FM instrument, each oscillator with its own envelope and level is called an operator, and the plan of which operators modulate which is an algorithm. The DX7 has six operators and 32 algorithms. A modulator can itself be modulated, several modulators can drive one carrier, and an operator fed back into itself turns its sine wave into something close to a sawtooth.
Common confusions
- FM and vibrato are the same process at different speeds. At an LFO rate you hear the pitch move; at audio rates the movement fuses into a new timbre.
- FM is not only digital. The idea works with analog oscillators too, but it needs stable, exact frequency ratios, which digital instruments provide far more easily.
- FM or phase modulation? Phase modulation is a close relative that produces the same family of sidebands, and the two are often treated as one technique.
Common questions
Why does FM synthesis sound metallic?
When the carrier and modulator frequencies are not in a simple whole-number ratio, the sidebands do not line up with a harmonic series. Those inharmonic components sound clangorous and metallic, a color that suits bells and cymbals. With ratios such as 1:1 or 1:2 the result is harmonic instead.
What is an operator in FM synthesis?
An oscillator together with its own envelope and level control. An operator can be a carrier, which you hear, or a modulator, which shapes the timbre of another operator. The arrangement of operators is called an algorithm.
Comments