Skip to main content
Back
Cover image for the Piano Chords for Small Hands: Share the Notes Between Your Hands blog article

Piano Chords for Small Hands: Share the Notes Between Your Hands

Some printed chords are wider than your hand can comfortably reach. Before changing the notes or rolling the chord, ask whether the other hand can take an inner note. This is redistribution: the pitches and timing stay the same while one note changes hands.

Work on paper, then test the split with your teacher. All examples are original; the numbers describe the puzzles, not your hands.

A staff does not dictate a hand

On a grand staff, the top staff is usually read by the right hand and the bottom staff by the left. That is a habit of the page, not a rule of the keyboard. The staves show which pitches to play. Who plays them is a second decision, and scores sometimes state it with the abbreviations m.d. for the right hand and m.s. for the left, from the Italian mano destra and mano sinistra. The pitch itself does not depend on the staff either: middle C is C4 whether it is written on a ledger line below the treble staff or on one above the bass staff.

Here is the chord we will use all lesson. Middle C is C4. The left hand plays E3 and G3. The right hand plays C4, E4 and C5, an octave with a note inside it.

A card titled "Five notes, and the right hand has to reach an octave" showing one measure on a grand staff in plain ink. The treble staff holds the right hand’s three notes, C4 on a ledger line below the staff, E4 on the bottom line and C5 in the third space. The bass staff holds the left hand’s E3 and G3 in adjacent spaces. Two cyan brackets at the right mark each hand: the right hand’s C4 to C5 is an octave, 12 semitones and 8 white keys; the left hand’s E3 to G3 is a minor third, 3 semitones and 3 white keys.

The lesson’s chord as printed, with each hand’s reach counted. The right hand’s C4 to C5 covers 12 semitones, or eight white keys; the left hand’s E3 to G3 covers 3 semitones, or three white keys. Whole notes keep the examples visually simple: play each chord together and let it sound for four slow quarter-note beats. The cards show separate chord events rather than a continuous metered passage.

On a standard keyboard the octave interval measures 6.5 inches (16.5 cm), the width of seven white keys. Playing C4 and C5 together covers eight white keys, about 7.4 inches (18.8 cm) from outer edge to outer edge, according to the table in a study of the hand spans of 473 adult pianists by Rhonda Boyle, Robin Boyle and Erica Booker. The same authors warn that a span measured flat on a surface does not tell you whether a pianist can play that interval comfortably. That is why this lesson counts reach but never tells you what yours should be.

Two small hands on the cream-colored keys of an upright piano with a reddish-brown case. Both hands are in playing position, the left further left and the right further right, their fingertips resting on white and black keys across several octaves.

Two hands at the keyboard of an upright piano. Every standard keyboard has the same key dimensions: an octave from C to the C above it covers eight white keys, about 7.4 inches from outer edge to outer edge. Photo: zaui/Scott Catron, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Teachers who work with small hands have a name for the move: redistribution. Lora Deahl and Brenda Wristen's book Adaptive Strategies for Small-Handed Pianists has a chapter by that title. Its abstract describes taking notes with the left hand that are printed for the right, or the reverse, and says this can mitigate or even eliminate problems caused by small handedness. It also says the work is mental first: you have to reconfigure the distribution printed on the score. An earlier conference paper by the same two authors lists "Redistribute notes between the hands." among its recommendations, and it advises against exercises or devices that claim to increase hand span.

A table of five sources with four columns: the source, what it is, what it supports in this lesson, and what it does not show. The rows are Deahl and Wristen 2017 (a book with a chapter called Redistribution), Wristen and Deahl 2002 (a conference paper for music teachers), the Royal Conservatory of Music 2020 (an examiner’s published answer), Boyle, Boyle and Booker 2015 (hand spans of 473 adult pianists, not a random sample) and the Music Encoding Initiative (guidelines that define a roll). The last column is in coral and says what each source cannot show.

What the sources in this lesson can and cannot carry. Four are teaching or measurement sources and one is a notation standard; none of them can say what your own hand can reach, which takes a teacher who can see you play.

Mark bass, melody and inner notes

Before you move anything, name each note's job. The bass is the lowest note. The top note is the highest, and in a lot of music it carries the tune, though you should check the score. Everything between them is an inner note. In our chord the bass is E3, the top note is C5 and the inner notes are E4, C4, G3.

The same one-measure chord on a grand staff, with three cyan brackets at the right. A short bracket at the top labels the top note C5, a tall bracket from E4 down across the gap between the staves to G3 labels the inner notes E4, C4 and G3, and a short bracket at the bottom labels the bass E3 and says it is the chord’s third, not its root.

Top note, inner notes and bass in the lesson’s chord, listed from the highest to the lowest. The bass is E3, the third of C major, so this is a first-inversion chord; the roles are about position, not about chord name.

The Triads & Their Inversions handout shows why E in the bass makes this C major in first inversion.

Why mark them? In this lesson the bass and the top note stay in the hands that already play them, and only an inner note travels, so the outline of the music does not change. That is a convention for these examples, not a law. The same conference paper lists "Use the thumb to express a tenor melody.", which implies that an inner voice can carry the tune. If a melody sits inside a chord, treat it as the note that must stay whole and ask your teacher before you reassign it. The Voicing and Balance handout notes that editions often show a plan with the melody's stems pointing up and the inner notes' stems pointing down.

With a pencil, put a B by the bass, a T over the top note and a line under each inner note.

Share one inner note

Now the move. Find the hand that has to reach too far: here it is the right hand, 12 semitones from C4 to C5. Its inner notes are C4 and E4, because C5 is the top note. Try the inner note nearest the other hand first, which is C4, and give it to the left hand.

Two measures of the chord on a grand staff, in plain ink with R.H. and L.H. labels. In the first measure, as printed, the right hand plays C4, E4 and C5 on the treble staff and the left hand plays E3 and G3 on the bass staff. In the second measure, C4 is written on a ledger line above the bass staff: the left hand plays E3, G3 and C4 and the right hand plays E4 and C5. A cyan arrow runs from C4 in the first measure to C4 in the second. Under the measures the left and right hands’ reach in semitones is printed: 3 and 12, then 8 and 8.

The same five sounds, E3 G3 C4 E4 C5, before and after sharing. C4 moves from the right hand to the left, the left hand’s reach grows from 3 to 8 semitones, and the right hand’s shrinks from 12 to 8. No pitch, rhythm or dynamic has changed.

The left hand now plays E3 G3 C4, a span of 8 semitones (a minor sixth, 6 white keys). The right hand plays E4 C5, also 8 semitones and 6 white keys. There were five notes before and there are five after. The only thing that changed is who plays one of them. The Wide Chord? Share the Inner Note handout prints this exact before and after, with audio.

Why C4 and not E4? Try the alternatives. If the left hand took E4, it would sit above the right hand's C4 and the hands would cross. If it took both C4 and E4, it would stretch 12 semitones with four notes.

Three measures of the chord on a grand staff, each a different way of moving right-hand notes to the left. First, C4 moved: left hand E3 G3 C4, right hand E4 C5, each hand reaching 8 semitones, labeled as fitting. Second, E4 moved: left hand E3 G3 E4, right hand C4 C5, labeled as crossing because the left hand’s E4 is higher than the right hand’s C4. Third, C4 and E4 moved: left hand E3 G3 C4 E4, right hand C5 alone, labeled as too wide with four notes across 12 semitones.

Three tries with the right hand’s inner notes. Only moving C4 keeps the hands uncrossed and each hand within 8 semitones. The other two keep every pitch and still fail the hand rules, which is why the hand rules matter.

A semitone is one move to the next key, black or white. Start at zero on the lower note and count each move to the higher note. E3 to C4 takes eight moves. The six white keys E–F–G–A–B–C are a separate count that includes both endpoints. Central Washington University’s fundamentals reference explains half steps and inclusive interval counts.

Here is the whole move as a routine.

  1. Find the hand with the widest reach and count its semitones.
  2. Mark the bass and the top note. They stay put.
  3. List the inner notes of the wide hand and try the one nearest the other hand first.
  4. Recount both hands, then count the notes. The total must not change.
  5. Play it with your teacher, who may keep it, change it or choose something else.

Of the 30 assignments that give each hand at least one of these five notes, four put every left-hand note below every right-hand note. Only one also keeps both spans within 8 semitones.

This lesson and the handout use an 8-semitone puzzle limit. The exercise prints a limit beside each task; some use 7 instead. These are practice constraints, not measurements of your hands. The Royal Conservatory's published answer on teaching students with small hands tells teachers to weigh a student's age, maturity and physical condition, and the conference paper says to take any complaint of pain or fatigue seriously. So the real limit is your teacher's call.

Two keyboard strips running from E3 to C5, thirteen white keys with the usual groups of black keys. In the first strip, labeled As printed, the five played keys E3, G3, C4, E4 and C5 are shaded; a bracket under E3 to G3 reads 3 semitones, 3 white keys for the left hand, and a bracket under C4 to C5 reads R.H. 12 semitones, 8 white keys. In the second strip, labeled Shared, the same five keys are shaded; the left-hand bracket runs E3 to C4 and reads 8 semitones, 6 white keys, and the right-hand bracket runs E4 to C5 and reads 8 semitones, 6 white keys. On the shared left-hand span, labels 0 through 8 count E, F, F-sharp, G, G-sharp, A, A-sharp, B and C.

The same five keys in both rows. Sharing changes which hand plays each key while preserving the written pitches and timing. White keys are counted from the lowest to the highest key of each hand, both included.

Moving the whole shape changes nothing about the idea. Raise every note a perfect fourth (four letter names including both endpoints, five semitones) and C major becomes F major: A3 and C4 in the left hand, F4, A4 and F5 in the right. F4 is now the note that changes hands, and each hand reaches 8 semitones afterward. All five notes are white keys, so the counts match the C version. In a key with black keys the semitone counts stay the same but the shape under your hand does not, so test each key on its own.

The F major version of the chord in two measures on a grand staff. As printed, the left hand plays A3 and C4 and the right hand plays F4, A4 and F5. Shared, F4 is written on the bass staff, so the left hand plays A3, C4 and F4 and the right hand plays A4 and F5. A cyan arrow marks the move, the reach of each hand is printed under each measure (3 and 12 semitones, then 8 and 8), and a line below lists the five notes moved up a perfect fourth: E3 to A3, G3 to C4, C4 to F4, E4 to A4 and C5 to F5.

The whole event up a perfect fourth. F4 is the note that changes hands, and each hand’s reach matches the C major version: 12 semitones reduced to 8 in the right hand, 3 grown to 8 in the left. The letter names change; the shape and the counts do not.

Check both hands' jobs together

A split that looks right can still be wrong. Run four checks in this order. Count the sounds: five before, five after, each pitch once and in the right octave. Place the notes: bass in the left hand, top note in the right, no crossing. Check the reach against your teacher's limit. Then listen: match the original attacks, note lengths, releases and balance, including any ties or articulation marks. A tied note must not be struck again merely because a hand assignment changes.

Four cards in a row, each with an icon and a short instruction: Check 1 Count (five sounds before, five after, each pitch once, in the right octave), Check 2 Place (bass in the left hand, top note in the right, hands never crossed), Check 3 Reach (each hand inside the limit your teacher sets for your hand) and Check 4 Listen (match attacks, lengths, releases and balance). A cream bar below reads Then look at what each hand has to do next.

The four checks to run after you move a note, in this order. The first two can be done with a pencil on paper; the last two need a keyboard and, for the limit in the third, your teacher.

Compare these rewrites pitch by pitch, even when the total stays five.

Four measures of the shared chord on a grand staff, each labeled underneath. The correct share has left hand E3 G3 C4 and right hand E4 C5. The wrong-octave version has left hand C3 E3 G3, with C written an octave low. The extra-note version has right hand E4 G4 C5, with a second G added. The missing-note version has right hand C5 alone, with E4 dropped. Each is labeled with its notes and what went wrong.

Three rewrites that pass the span check but change a pitch or the note count: C3 replaces C4, G4 is added, and E4 is dropped. Compare every pitch and octave, not just the total. The wrong-octave rewrite also changes the bass from E3 to C3.

Recording helps. Play the original chord if a teacher or friend can reach it, or use the worksheet audio, then record your own split on a phone. Listen to both with your eyes closed. If the versions differ, first check pitches and simultaneous attacks, then compare how long the notes last and how strongly each one sounds. Keep the transferred inner note at its original balance beneath the melody.

Check the approach, the chord's full written length and the next entrance. For this hypothetical test, use no pedal: the left hand must hold C4 from beat 1 until beat 5, but it must also play E2 on beat 3. That requires an impossible simultaneous reach for this lesson's hand limits, so reconsider the split.

An original timeline with no pedal: the left hand holds the C4 key from beat 1 until beat 5 and must also play E2 on beat 3. Its required simultaneous reach is 20 semitones, beyond the lesson’s 8-semitone limit. C4 key releases at beat 5; the same hand’s E2 entrance is two beats earlier.

Without pedal, this left-hand E2 entrance arrives two beats before the same hand may release C4. The isolated chord's span check misses the overlap.

Once you propose a split, test its fingering too. One candidate for E3–G3–C4 in the left hand is 5–3–1, with 1–5 for E4–C5 in the right. These are trial numbers, not a prescription. Check the inner spacing and the approach to each note with your teacher; a split that meets the puzzle's span limit can still need another fingering or another adaptation. See Fingering Principles.

Redistribution versus rolling versus omission

A wide chord has three common answers, and they are not interchangeable.

Three measures of the chord on a grand staff, labeled Share, Roll and Omit. Share: left hand E3 G3 C4, right hand E4 C5, five pitches all on the beat. Roll: the printed layout, left hand E3 G3 and right hand C4 E4 C5, with a wavy vertical roll sign before the right-hand chord, five pitches spread in time. Omit: left hand E3 G3 and right hand E4 C5, with C4 not played at all, four pitches.

Share, roll and omit side by side. The wavy line in the middle measure is the roll sign. Only the first measure keeps every pitch and every start time; the roll keeps every pitch and the omission keeps every start time.

Sharing, or redistributing, keeps every pitch and every start time and changes who plays one note. Rolling keeps every pitch and changes when the notes start. The Music Encoding Initiative's guidelines define the arpeggiation sign as showing that the notes of a chord are performed successively rather than simultaneously, usually from lowest to highest, and call the modern symbol a vertical wavy line before the chord; they note it is sometimes called a roll. Omitting leaves a note out, so the pitches themselves change: our chord loses its C4.

In our rolled version the left hand's two notes and C4 start on the beat, E4 starts a quarter beat later and C5 half a beat later. This roll is deliberately slow so you can see and hear it. Rolling lets the hand move through a chord instead of reaching every key at once. Do not try to keep the full wide shape stretched under your fingers. Which keys can release, and whether pedal should sustain their sound, depend on the passage; plan those with your teacher. The timing diagram shows sounding events, not which fingers remain on keys.

Three piano-roll style panels for the first beat, one row per note: C5, E4, C4, G3 and E3 from top to bottom. In Share every bar starts on beat 1. In Roll, C4, G3 and E3 start on beat 1, E4 starts a quarter beat later and C5 half a beat later. In Omit, every bar starts on beat 1 except that the C4 row is empty.

When each note starts. The quarter-beat steps in the roll are exaggerated so you can see them; at quarter note = 60 they are a quarter of a second apart, deliberately slow.

The Royal Conservatory's answer lists rolling chords discreetly and omitting notes from large chords among valid strategies for small hands, and it says redistributing can sometimes make an awkward passage manageable. The conference paper lists omitting notes from successive large chords. So neither alternative is a mistake. Sometimes both hands are busy and no hand is free to take a note, and a roll may be the better answer. What matters is calling each by its name: sharing moves a note, rolling moves its start and omitting removes it. Which one fits a passage, and which note to leave out, belongs to your teacher.

Three cards compared by pitches, timing and what changes. Share: all five pitches, all on the beat, changes who plays one note. Roll: all five pitches; E3, G3 and C4 start together, followed by E4 and C5. This changes when notes start. Omit: four of five pitches, all on the beat, changes the sound of the chord. The counts are for the lesson’s C chord.

Share, roll or omit: what each one keeps and what each one changes. Here only the right hand rolls; the left-hand notes stay together on the beat.

Section 3 of the Wide Chord? handout lays the shared and rolled versions side by side with a start-time table and audio for both.

Four original adaptations with teacher choices

Here are four more chords, all original, adapted under the same rules: bass left, top note right, no crossing, at most three notes a hand and 8 semitones a hand. Each arrow shows the one note that moves.

Two before-and-after pairs on a grand staff, with an arrow marking each move and each hand’s reach printed under every measure. G major: as printed the left hand plays G3 B3 and the right hand D4 B4 (9 semitones); D4 moves to the left hand, so the left hand plays G3 B3 D4 and the right hand plays B4 alone. F major: as printed the left hand plays F3 and the right hand C4 F4 A4 (9 semitones); C4 moves to the left hand, so the left hand plays F3 C4 and the right hand plays F4 A4.

Two adaptations at an 8-semitone limit: in G major the left hand takes the whole triad and the right hand keeps the top note alone; in F major the left hand takes the open fifth F3 and C4.

The next two examples give a note from the left hand to the right.

Two before-and-after pairs on a grand staff, with an arrow marking each move and each hand’s reach printed under every measure. D minor: as printed the left hand plays A2 D3 F3 A3 (12 semitones) and the right hand D4; A3 moves to the right hand, so the left hand plays A2 D3 F3 and the right hand plays A3 D4. A minor: as printed the left hand plays C3 E3 A3 (9 semitones) and the right hand E4; A3 moves to the right hand, so the left hand plays C3 E3 and the right hand plays A3 E4.

Two adaptations where the left hand gives a note away. In D minor the left hand started with four notes across 12 semitones; in A minor it started at 9 and ends at 4.

Here is where the teacher's choice comes in. At a limit of 8 semitones each chord has exactly one legal split. Raise the limit to 10 and each has two. The G major, F major and A minor chords can then stay as printed, because their widest hand reaches only 9 semitones; only D minor still needs a move, because its left hand spans 12. Its second option gives the right hand F3, A3 and D4 and leaves the left hand A2 D3. A student who can reach 10 semitones comfortably may need no change at all, and another teacher may prefer a different split for fingering, pedaling or the chord that follows. Rolling or omitting are still on the table too. Two things stay fixed whatever limit you choose: every pitch is played once, and the bass and the top note keep their hands.

Two fingers resting on adjacent white piano keys, seen from a low angle. The fingertips are relaxed on the keys, with more white and black keys receding in soft focus behind them.

Fingers at the keys. Whatever limit your teacher sets, the test is always at the keyboard: counting on paper gives you a candidate; playing it tells you whether it works. Photo: Hans Braxmeier, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Annotate your score and compare the sound

When a split is settled, write it on a copy, in pencil. An arrow and m.s. or m.d. beside the moved note is enough: the page stays readable and you and your teacher can revise the split. The Fingering Principles handout gives the same advice for numbers, which are best written in pencil, close to the note, and only where they matter.

The printed chord in one measure on a grand staff with no R.H. or L.H. labels, as on a published page, and a cyan arrow leaving C4 in the treble staff and pointing down toward the bass staff, ending beside the pencil mark m.s. in italics. A note at the right says to put an arrow and m.s., for left hand, beside C4 and to leave everything else on the page alone.

A pencil mark on your own copy: an arrow and m.s. (left hand) beside C4. Your teacher can revise or erase the mark. Use m.d. for a note that goes to the right hand.

Compare each hand alone, then together, keeping the original lengths and balance. The handout supplies a controlled audio model.

A plain-ink musical example from Wide Chord? Share the Inner Note, rebuilt for this blog rather than a worksheet screenshot, beside a list of its contents: two original chords engraved as printed with a bass, top note and inner notes to name; the shared chord with each hand’s span in semitones; a rolled version with the start time of every note; an F major Try it with a printed key; and audio for the printed, shared and rolled versions.

The Wide Chord? Share the Inner Note handout puts this lesson’s chord, the shared version and the rolled version on one page, with audio. The audio plays the printed and shared chords with identical notes and loudness so you can hear that they match.

Try this on paper before looking back: left hand F3; right hand C4–F4–A4. Keep the bass left and the top note right, with no overlapping hand ranges, no more than three notes per hand and a 7-semitone limit. Which note changes hands, and what does each hand play?

A plain-ink musical example from Redistribute the Chord: Keep Every Sound, rebuilt for this blog rather than a worksheet screenshot, beside a list of its parts: four chord cards each with a marked note to move, three chords to split yourself under printed limits where only one answer fits, four rewrites that each changed the sound (missing, extra, wrong octave or wrong note), check clips to play only after you answer, and a printed key.

Redistribute the Chord: Keep Every Sound: For Parts 1 and 2, each check clip plays the original and then the prepared correct adaptation; those versions should match in sound. The four Part 3 rewrite clips deliberately change a pitch or the note count. Listen after answering.

Answer: move C4 left. L.H. F3–C4 spans 7 semitones; R.H. F4–A4 spans 4. All four pitches remain.

Five cards in a row, each with an icon and a one-line instruction for adding a hand split to your music: Step 1 Copy (work in pencil on a copy of the bar), Step 2 Mark (circle bass and top note, arrow the note that moves), Step 3 Check (run the four checks, then play each hand alone), Step 4 Compare (listen to the original and the split side by side) and Step 5 Show (ask your teacher before you keep it).

A routine for adding a split to your music: copy, mark, check, compare, show your teacher.

Free worksheets for this lesson

Bring it to a teacher

A split on paper is a proposal. A piano teacher can watch your hand, hear whether both hands land together and choose between sharing, rolling and leaving a note out for the piece in front of you. Questions worth bringing:

  • Which limit should I use for each hand right now?
  • Which note should I give away when two choices both fit?
  • Should the pedal join the notes, or would you rather I release some early?
  • Is there a place in this piece where a roll is better than a share?

If you want a teacher who can work on this with you, Tissimo's piano teachers give live one-on-one lessons online.

Sources

Read this article online: https://tissimo.co/articles/piano-small-hands-chord-redistribution

Was this useful?
Dislike buttonLike button
Thank you for your feedback imageThanks for your feedback

Comments