Skip to main content
Back
Cover image for the Piano Plugins Compared: Pianoteq 9, sfizz with the Salamander Grand Piano, and Your DAW's Own Piano blog article

Piano Plugins Compared: Pianoteq 9, sfizz with the Salamander Grand Piano, and Your DAW's Own Piano

If you play a digital piano or a MIDI keyboard into a computer, the piano plugin decides how your playing sounds and feels: how soft notes respond and what the sustain pedal does. How quickly you hear each note depends mostly on your audio settings, which we cover too. This guide compares two very different plugins, Modartt's Pianoteq 9 (a modeled piano, paid, with a free trial) and the free sfizz player loading the free Salamander Grand Piano (a sampled piano), along with the pianos already built into Ableton Live, FL Studio and Logic Pro. Both plugins appear in real, annotated screenshots, every piano gets honest pros and cons, and five setup tips follow. Prices and versions are as of November 2026.

New to plugins? The VST plugin guide explains formats and installation. If velocity and controller numbers are new words, MIDI Explained covers them first.

Modeled vs sampled pianos

A sampled piano plays back recordings. Someone records a real piano note by note at several playing strengths, and when you press a key the plugin picks the recording that matches your note and how hard you played. The Salamander Grand Piano, for example, was recorded from a Yamaha C5 at 16 strengths (velocity layers), sampling every third semitone from the lowest A; the notes in between are recordings shifted in pitch.

A modeled piano plays back no recorded notes. Pianoteq calculates each note while you play, from equations for the hammer, strings, soundboard and resonances. Modartt's manual points out that every one of the 127 MIDI velocities then gets its own tone, where a sample library would need "hundreds of gigabytes" to record all of them.

Diagram in two rows. Modeled: key press, equations computed, sound, with a smooth velocity bar from 1 to 127 and the note about 50 MB. Sampled: key press, a recording picked by velocity, sound, with a bar split into 16 velocity layers and the note about 0.7 GB for Salamander and 1.48 GB for Ableton's Grand Piano

How each kind of piano makes a note. The sampled row's bar shows the Salamander Grand Piano's real velocity layers, read from its SFZ file: 1–26, 27–34 and so on up to 121–127.

Each approach has a cost. Recordings capture a real instrument and its room, but they take disk space and memory, and the tone changes in steps from one velocity layer to the next. Models are tiny and respond smoothly, but they can still be told from a recording: Robin Bigwood, reviewing Pianoteq 9 for Sound On Sound, writes that he can still find "the potential for fleeting (and hard-to-define) unnaturalness" when he sets out to look for it, while calling it one of the best options available.

What matters for practice and recording

Five things decide whether a piano plugin works for you:

  • Velocity response. Your keyboard sends a velocity from 1 to 127 for each note. A good plugin lets you reshape how those numbers turn into loudness and tone (the velocity curve), so your softest and loudest playing land where you expect.
  • Sustain pedal. Most pedals send controller 64. A simple switch pedal sends only on or off; a progressive (continuous) pedal sends in-between values, which a plugin needs for half pedaling.
  • Latency. The delay between pressing a key and hearing it depends mostly on your audio buffer size in the DAW, not on the plugin.
  • Disk and memory. The two sampled pianos sized here take about 0.7 GB and 1.48 GB, and larger libraries exist; Pianoteq takes about 50 MB.
  • Processing load. Modeled pianos calculate every note, so they lean on the processor instead of the disk.

Here is how the five pianos in this guide compare on paper.

Table comparing five pianos: Pianoteq 9 Stage, modeled, about 50 MB, 139 dollars with a free trial, VST3, AU, AAX and standalone; sfizz plus Salamander, sampled with 16 velocity layers, about 0.7 GB, free; Ableton's Grand Piano Pack, 1.48 GB, included with Live 12 Standard and Suite; FL Keys, included in all FL Studio editions; Logic Pro's Studio Piano, included with Logic Pro

The lineup at a glance. The facts come from each developer's own pages, except Salamander's size, which is the size of its sample files; the last column is our summary.

Pianoteq 9: a modeled piano

Pianoteq comes from Modartt in France; version 9.3.1 is current. It runs as a standalone app and as a VST3, AU or AAX plugin on Windows, macOS and Linux, plus iOS (Modartt lists no CLAP version). There are three feature levels: Stage ($139), Standard ($269) and PRO ($399); a Studio Bundle ($929) is PRO with every instrument pack. Stage, the one shown here, includes two instrument packs of your choice plus free historical instruments; Standard adds tweaking of the piano model and moving the virtual microphones.

The free trial needs no registration and includes every feature and instrument, with two limits: eight black keys are silent, and it must be restarted after 20 minutes. Counting middle C as C4, the silent keys are F♯2, G♯2 and A♯2 in the bass and C♯6, D♯6, F♯6, G♯6 and A♯6 in the treble (Modartt's own list names them an octave lower, F♯1 to A♯1 and C♯5 to A♯5, because it counts middle C as C3). That is plenty to test it with your own keyboard before you buy.

Pianoteq 9.3.1 Stage trial window playing the NY Steinway D Classical preset with a C major chord held: coral boxes mark the preset name, the VELOCITY curve panel, the level meter with Volume and Dynamics, the Mics and 440 Hz buttons, the four pedals and the Action and Effects panel; the keys C4, E4 and G4 are lit red

Pianoteq 9.3.1 (Stage, trial version) with the NY Steinway D Classical preset and a C major chord held: the keys light up red and the level meter moves. The window shows the trial's DEMO stamp.

Who it suits: pianists who practice at the computer and care about touch and pedaling, and anyone with a small laptop drive.

Pros: about 50 MB to install and quick to load; velocity, pedal and aftertouch curves plus a keyboard calibration assistant, even in Stage; a progressive sustain pedal with half pedaling; binaural presets for headphones; VST3, AU and AAX formats, so it loads in Live, FL Studio, Logic Pro and Pro Tools.

Cons: it costs money, and each extra instrument pack is $49. Stage can't move microphones or tweak the piano model. The model works the processor rather than the disk, so on a slow computer you may need to lower its polyphony. Sound On Sound's reviewer hears "a couple of surprisingly stiff-sounding bass notes" in some of the NY Steinway D presets.

The library button opens every preset, sorted by instrument. Each grand piano comes with several presets, such as Classical, Jazz and Sombre, and most have a Binaural one; Sound On Sound singles out the Sombre presets for "a lovely combination of warmth and intimacy".

Pianoteq preset library with coral boxes on the library button, the preset list sorted by instrument, starting with the NY Steinway D presets from Classical to Gentle, the instrument filter from Steinway D to Xylo, and the notes on the selected preset

The preset library. The instrument filter on the right narrows the list to one instrument; in the trial, all of them play in demo mode.

sfizz with the Salamander Grand Piano: free and sampled

sfizz is a free, open-source SFZ player (BSD-2-Clause license) from the SFZTools team. SFZ is a plain-text format that maps sample files across the keyboard, so sfizz is really a player and the piano is a separate download. Version 1.2.3, released January 14, 2024, is the current one, as VST3, AU and LV2 on Windows, macOS and Linux. sfizz streams samples from disk as you play instead of loading them all into memory.

The piano here is the Salamander Grand Piano V3 by Alexander Holm: a Yamaha C5 recorded at 48 kHz/24-bit with two microphones about 12 cm above the strings. Holm released it under CC BY 3.0 and declared it public domain on March 4, 2022. The SFZ edition shown here, remapped by kinwie in the sfzinstruments repository on GitHub, still carries a CC BY 3.0 notice, so credit the author if you share it.

sfizz 1.2.3 with Salamander Grand Piano V3 loaded: coral boxes on the instrument name, the keyswitch reading C 0 Natural, the voice and memory readout, the Volume and Pan knobs, the page buttons and the keyboard with the chord in blue

sfizz 1.2.3 playing a C major chord: Voices 6, Max 64, Memory 89 MB. The empty middle of the window was cut out.

Who it suits: anyone who wants a recorded acoustic grand for nothing, in any DAW that loads VST3, AU or LV2 plugins.

Pros: free and open source; a real recorded grand with 16 velocity layers; controls for string resonance, hammer noise, pedal noise, release and velocity response; plays other SFZ instruments too.

Cons: the sample files take about 0.7 GB as FLAC; you download and unpack the piano yourself; the sustain pedal works as an on/off switch here (sfizz 1.2.3 treats any pedal value above zero as fully down, and this SFZ file defines no half-pedal behavior); both sfizz repositories on GitHub were archived (made read-only) in June 2026, so don't expect new versions; no AAX for Pro Tools. The Salamander README also warns that this edition was built for ARIA-based players such as Plogue's sforzando and may misbehave in others.

Setting it up takes three steps. Install sfizz from the SFZTools downloads page. On the Salamander repository's GitHub page, choose Code, then Download ZIP (about 0.7 GB), and unpack it somewhere permanent, because sfizz plays the samples from that folder. Then add sfizz to a MIDI track, open the menu next to the instrument name, choose Load file and pick Salamander Grand Piano V3.sfz. The arrows step through the other SFZ files in the same folder.

The top bar of sfizz with the file menu open, listing Load file, Edit file, Create new file and Open SFZ folder; coral boxes mark the instrument name and the menu

Load file picks any .sfz file on your drive. The keyswitch C0 selects the Natural tuning and C♯0 the Retuned one; both keys lie below the lowest A of an 88-key keyboard, and Natural is loaded by default.

The gear icon opens the engine settings, which you can leave at their defaults at first.

sfizz Settings page with coral boxes on Memory 89 MB, Engine options with Preload size 32 kB and Oversampling 1x, Rendering quality set to Polynomial, and the Tuning section at 440.0 Hz

The Settings page: Preload size 32 kB, Oversampling 1x, Sample quality Polynomial (Sinc 72 when freewheeling, that is, when your DAW renders an export offline). In this capture the window reads Memory 89 MB, while the samples on disk take about 0.7 GB: sfizz loads sounds on demand instead of all at once.

Plenty of other free pianos exist, but several need an account or an email address before you can download them, so they are not compared here.

Five setup tips, shown on real screenshots

These are starting points, not rules. Change one thing, play the same passage again, and keep what feels right under your hands.

1. Fit the velocity curve to your touch

Every keyboard action reports velocity a little differently. If your loud notes never reach fortissimo, or soft notes vanish, bend the curve.

Line chart of three velocity curves from 0 to 127: lighter touch bends up and turns input velocity 50 into 73, linear keeps 50, and heavier touch bends down to 29

Three curves computed from one formula. A key press at velocity 50 plays as 73, 50 or 29 depending on the curve.

In Pianoteq, click Calibration under the velocity panel and follow the assistant: it guides you through playing and adjusts the curve, and the pedal response too if you have a progressive pedal. Modartt's manual strongly recommends doing this at least once. Before you start, choose your keyboard's own touch setting if it has one; then fine-tune by dragging the curve's points. To check the result, play one C at six levels from pp to ff, as on the Dynamic Ladder worksheet: you should hear six distinct steps.

Pianoteq lower panel with the velocity curve, the Calibration button, the Keyboard calibration assistant text and its Start button boxed in coral

Calibration opens the Keyboard calibration assistant. The curve on the left is the default straight line from ppp to fff.

sfizz has no curve editor, but the Salamander instrument has a Veltrack knob (controller 99) on the Controls page. It sets how much velocity changes the volume: the SFZ loads it at 73%, which shows as 93 on the knob. Lower it if your soft notes disappear; raise it for more contrast.

sfizz Controls page with coral boxes on the Veltrack knob at 64 labeled CC 99, the String Res, Hammer Noise and Pedal Noise knobs at 64, the Release knob at 64 and the Controls page button

Veltrack turned down to 64 (the plugin reads back 0.5039): softer notes now come out relatively louder.

2. Check your sustain pedal

Play a chord, press the pedal and lift your hands: the notes should keep sounding. In Pianoteq you can also see it: the right-hand pedal on screen goes down, and the PEDAL page of the velocity panel shows how the pedal's input maps to the damper position.

Pianoteq lower panel with the PEDAL curve rising from input 25 to full at about 95, Damper mode Normal, the sustain pedal drawn pressed and the other three pedals up, all boxed in coral

The sustain pedal is fully down (the plugin reports 1.00), and the right-hand pedal is drawn pressed. The default PEDAL curve ignores the first 25 of 127 steps, so resting your foot lightly on the pedal does not lift the dampers.

For half pedaling you need a progressive pedal and a plugin that follows it. Pianoteq does: its manual says a progressive pedal is required for partial pedaling. sfizz with this Salamander file treats the pedal as simply down or up. When to press and lift is a playing question: see How to Use the Sustain Pedal on Piano and the Damper Pedal worksheet.

3. Pick a listening position for headphones

Many presets place virtual microphones around the piano, as a recording would. For practice on headphones, try a binaural preset: Pianoteq models a listener's head at the keyboard, which its manual says can sound more realistic in headphones. In the library, choose NY Steinway D Binaural, then open Mics to see where the "ears" are.

Pianoteq Mics view for the NY Steinway D Binaural preset with coral boxes on the virtual head in the top view, the headphones in the front view, the message that Standard or PRO is needed to move microphones, the Left ear and Right ear channels and the Mic Presets menu

Two channels, Left ear and Right ear, replace the usual microphones. In Stage you can switch presets but not move the head.

For recording a song, a miked preset may sit better in a mix. Logic's Studio Piano has its own version: level sliders for a condenser pair, a ribbon pair and a mono ribbon mic.

4. Set your buffer for low latency

The buffer size in your DAW's audio settings controls most of the delay you feel. Smaller buffers respond faster but work the computer harder; when it can't keep up, you hear clicks and crackles. Apple's Logic Pro guide recommends the smallest buffer that plays without clicks while you record, and the largest while you mix. Image-Line's FL Studio manual calls 5–10 ms excellent and suggests 10 ms (441 samples at 44.1 kHz) as a good target. On Windows, use your audio interface's ASIO driver: Pianoteq's manual says ASIO drivers are required for low latency.

Ableton Live 12.4.15 Audio settings with coral boxes on the Scarlett 4i4 input and output, the 44100 sample rate, the 512 Samples buffer size and an overall latency of 29.6 ms

Live 12.4.15's Audio settings, from our latency article: at 44,100 Hz and 512 samples, Live reports 29.6 ms overall latency. That article treats 512 as a mixing setting and suggests trying 128 samples while you play, then 256 if it crackles.

If a lower buffer crackles with Pianoteq, its Options window has a Perf tab: Modartt says a lower internal sample rate or maximum polyphony reduces the processing load. Fix Latency, Crackles and Bad Exports in Ableton Live 12 walks through the whole audio setup.

Pianoteq Options window on the Perf tab with coral boxes on the tab, Internal sample rate 48000 Hz, Buffer size 512 samples and Maximum polyphony 48

The Perf tab: Internal sample rate 48000 Hz, Buffer size 512 samples (set by the host), Maximum polyphony 48. The CPU section above was cut out.

5. Set the dynamic range

Pianoteq's Dynamics slider sets the distance between pianissimo and fortissimo. Modartt's manual notes that acoustic pianos measure about 50 dB and suggests 20 to 60 dB; lowering the setting raises the soft notes while the loudest stay the same. Recorded piano is often compressed to a narrower range, the manual adds, so a lower setting can help a piano sit in a busy mix; for practice, a wider range lets you hear your own dynamics.

Pianoteq lower panel with coral boxes on the level meter, the Dynamics slider moved left, and the unchanged velocity curve

Dynamics lowered from 45 dB to 29 dB. The velocity curve is unchanged: Dynamics changes how loud each note comes out, not which velocity the piano receives.

In sfizz, Veltrack (tip 1) does a similar job for the Salamander piano.

Using them in Ableton Live, FL Studio and Logic Pro

Install the format your DAW reads; the VST plugin guide walks through installation.

  • Ableton Live 12 loads VST2, VST3 and, on Mac, Audio Units; use the VST3 of Pianoteq or sfizz. Live 12 Standard and Suite include Ableton's Grand Piano Pack (1.48 GB installed), sampled with multiple dynamic layers, with Macro controls for velocity, tone and noises. Limits: the Pack page lists it for Standard and Suite only, so Live 12 Intro users need another piano, and it plays only inside Live.
  • FL Studio loads VST2, VST3 and CLAP on Windows and Mac, plus AU on Mac: use the VST3 here, since neither plugin offers CLAP. FL Keys, Image-Line's own sampled piano, is described as light on CPU and memory, and has Sensitivity, Hardness and Muffle knobs for velocity. Image-Line's edition comparison lists it as included in all editions. Limits: the manual lists those three velocity knobs but no velocity-curve editor and no pedal settings, and FL Keys runs only inside FL Studio.
  • Logic Pro loads third-party plugins only as Audio Units, so install the AU of Pianoteq or sfizz. Logic's Studio Piano is a sampled instrument with Studio Grand, Concert Grand and Vintage Upright pianos, plus levels for pedal noise, key noise, release samples and sympathetic resonance. Limits: the parameter list in Apple's guide has no velocity-response control, and Studio Piano exists only in Logic Pro.

The built-in piano is enough for sketching songs, for simple chords under other parts, and when you want a project to open on another computer without installing anything extra. Reach for Pianoteq when the touch or pedal response of your keyboard matters, and for sfizz with Salamander when you want a free recorded grand that works in Live, FL Studio, Logic Pro and most other DAWs (not Pro Tools). For more picks per DAW, see the guides for Ableton Live 12, FL Studio and Logic Pro.

Which piano plugin should you use?

Start with what you have. Load your DAW's piano, run through the five tips, and play a piece you know well. If soft passages feel uneven or the pedal feels like a switch, download the Pianoteq trial and play the same piece; if you want a recorded grand at no cost, add sfizz and Salamander.

Decision guide with six cards: touch and pedaling, Pianoteq 9; a free recorded grand in most DAWs, sfizz plus Salamander; Ableton Live 12 Standard or Suite, Grand Piano; FL Studio, FL Keys; Logic Pro, Studio Piano; little free disk space, Pianoteq 9; with a footnote that only Pianoteq comes as AAX

Pick the line that sounds most like you. You can keep more than one piano installed.

If you'd like help with the setup, a Tissimo piano teacher can watch you play in a live lesson and help you set the touch and pedal so the plugin responds to your fingers.

Free worksheets for this lesson

  • The Dynamic Ladder: the six levels from pp to ff, with a one-key exercise that doubles as a velocity check.
  • The Damper Pedal: what the right pedal does and how to change it cleanly between chords.

Sources

Read this article online: https://tissimo.co/articles/piano-plugins-compared-pianoteq-and-free-piano-plugins

Was this useful?
Dislike buttonLike button
Thank you for your feedback imageThanks for your feedback

Comments