
How to Start Composing Music: A Beginner's Path From Motif to First Piece
The hardest part of composing is the blank page, and the way around it is to stop starting with a blank page. Start with a scrap: three or four notes and a rhythm. A scrap can be repeated, moved, turned upside down, answered and harmonized, and those few moves are enough to build a finished piece. This path has six steps, and every step ends with something you can play. If you play a little and want to write your own music, you need only an instrument, a pencil and a phone.

The six steps. Each one produces an object, such as a recording, a motif, a phrase or a score, so you can stop and play at any point.
All the notated examples are original and written in C major and 4/4, so you can play them as they are. A pencil and staff paper work, and so do a notation program or a recording program (a DAW). Use whichever you will actually open. The tool matters less than the habit of finishing small things.
Step 1: Capture ideas before you judge them
Ideas arrive while you are doing something else, and they are gone in a minute. So the first skill is catching them. Keep your phone's voice-memo app one tap away. When something turns up, hum or play it for ten seconds, say the date and one word, and move on. Do not evaluate it yet.

A four-part idea habit. The rating step happens once a week, never in the moment.
Once a week, listen to your memos and star the two you still like. Write the first notes or the rhythm of those two on staff paper, in pencil. If you cannot write the pitches yet, write the rhythm alone, or the contour as a line that rises and falls; pitches can come in step 2.
A few habits make the pile more useful later. Record the idea twice if you can: once as it came, once slower and cleaner. Say aloud where beat 1 falls, or tap it, so you can find the bar lines when you transcribe. Hum into the phone away from a television or a fan, and keep the memos in one folder. Most scraps will turn out to be ordinary, and that is fine: you are not looking for a masterpiece, only for one idea that makes you want to play it again.
Constraint: ten scraps in a week, each under fifteen seconds. Quantity first; you are building a pile to choose from.
Step 2: Turn a scrap into a motif
A motif is a short musical idea, often just a few notes, with a rhythm and a shape you can recognize when it comes back. Our Motif and sequence sheet puts it this way: composers rarely write a brand-new idea in every bar, and spotting the motif turns a page of notes into a few shapes you already know. For more on how famous pieces grow from small cells, see What Is a Motif?.
Take your favorite scrap and make it one bar long. Ours is E E F G in 4/4 (the first four pitches of Ode to Joy, but with a new rhythm and continuation): a quarter note, two eighths and a half note, so the rhythm is long, short, short, long. Now use it four ways (the figure shows all four):
- Repeat it on the same notes.
- Sequence it: play the same shape starting one step higher (F F G A).
- Invert it: every step goes the other way (E E D C).
- Keep only its head: the first two or three notes.

Bar 1: the motif. Bar 2: an exact repeat. Bar 3: the same shape one step higher, a sequence. Bar 4: the shape upside down. Bar 5: only the head, E E F, then silence. The rhythm stays the same in bars 1–4, which is why you hear them as one idea.
The Find the motif and the sequence exercise gives you four tunes (the last from Für Elise) and asks you to label each return of the motif as a repeat, a sequence, a varied return or something new. It trains the ear you will use on your own bars.
Constraint: use only the notes C to A (six notes), and one rhythm, for the whole exercise. Limits make choices easier.
Step 3: Shape a phrase, then a period
A phrase is a complete musical thought, often four bars long, and it stops somewhere that feels like punctuation. Phrase and period describes the two stops: a phrase that ends on the V chord sounds open, like a comma, and one that goes V to I sounds closed, like a full stop. Musicians call these a half cadence and an authentic cadence. If cadences are new, Cadences lets you hear both.
Two phrases that belong together make a period. Open Music Theory describes the period as generally eight measures long, with two four-measure phrases called antecedent and consequent: the first ends with a weaker cadence, the second restates the opening idea and ends with a strong one.
Start with rhythm, because rhythm is easier to plan than pitch. Write four bars of rhythm with this plan: the motif rhythm, the motif rhythm again, a busier bar of eighth notes, then one long note to land on.

A rhythm template. Every note sits on B for now; keep the rhythm and choose your own pitches. Our own phrase puts the motif in bar 1, the sequence in bar 2, a winding run of eighth notes in bar 3 and a long D in bar 4.
Play each phrase and breathe at its end, as a singer would. If you run out of breath before the stop, the phrase is too busy or too long. Fill the template with pitches from your motif, and end bar 4 on a note that sounds unfinished: for us, D. Then write the answer. Begin exactly as the first phrase began, and change the ending so it lands on C.

A period. Bars 1–4 are the question and stop on D. Bars 5 and 6 repeat bars 1 and 2, then bars 7–8 come down to a long C. Bar 7 ends on a low B, a half step below the C it leads to. The labels a and a′ mark the answer: it starts like the question and changes its ending.
If you want a different shape for your first phrase, a sentence (a basic idea, its repeat, then a push to the end) is just as useful; see The Musical Sentence. For the melody itself, How to Write a Melody goes deeper than we can here.
Constraint: the answer must begin with your first phrase's opening bar and may not end where the question ended.
Step 4: Harmonize with I, IV, V and vi
To harmonize a melody, you choose chords to play under it. Choosing chords for a melody boils it down to three questions: which chord owns the important notes, how often to change, and where each phrase ends. Plan the endings first. Here the first phrase ends on V and the second on V7 to I, so bars 4, 7 and 8 are fixed. Then fill in the middle.
In C major the four chords are I (C E G), IV (F A C), V (G B D) and vi (A C E). The notes on strong beats, beats 1 and 3, pick the chord: it must contain them. Bar 2 has F on beat 1 and A on beat 3, and both belong to F major, so bar 2 gets an F chord.

Four chords and one chord per bar. The first phrase ends on V (G), the second on G7 and then C.

The same eight bars with chord symbols. Bar 7 has G, F, D and B, all notes of G7, so a G7 chord fits the whole bar.
Open Music Theory groups chords by function: in a major key, I, iii and vi are tonic, ii and IV subdominant, and V and vii° dominant, with the note that the groups are a general guide. That is why vi can stand in for I as a softer home, and why you hear IV as a step away from home before V leans back. Try it: play the last bar with Am instead of C and listen to how unfinished it sounds. The primary chords sheet gives you I, IV and V to loop with your left hand, and Harmonize a melody is a short exercise in picking I, IV or V7 for each bar. For popular-music patterns, see common chord progressions.
Constraint: three chords first (I, IV, V). Add vi only where a bar sounds too plain.
Step 5: Choose a form: A B A
You now have eight good bars. A piece needs a plan for what happens next, and the simplest plan is A B A: say something, contrast it, say it again. In Open Music Theory's account of the small ternary, the first and last parts are tight-knit units that each end with a cadence, and the contrasting middle has dominant harmony at its close.
Ours is A (the eight bars), then four bars of B, then A again, twenty bars in all.

Block widths are proportional to bars. At 100 quarter notes per minute, twenty bars of 4/4 last 48 seconds.
Make B different in three ways: start on a different chord, move to a different register and slow the notes down. Ours starts on vi (Am), sits higher, and moves in half notes, ending on G so the return of A sounds like arriving home.

Section B. Bars 9–12 move in half notes, higher than the A section, over Am, F, C and G. The last chord is V.
Musical form gives the letter system (a changed return is A′, new music takes the next letter), and Binary, rounded binary and ternary shows how to tell the forms apart. Try Label the form on real pieces and you will see A B A in places you had not noticed. For rondo and sonata see binary, ternary, rondo and sonata; for songs, song structure.
When A returns, you may copy it note for note or change the ending slightly. The copy is the safer choice for a first piece. A small change, such as a higher last note or an added bar of silence, is a good second experiment once the plain version works.
Constraint: B may not use the motif at all. If B sounds like a different piece, you are doing it right.
Step 6: Arrange for your instrument, then notate or record
Arranging means deciding who plays what. For piano, the simplest arrangement is the melody in the right hand and the root and fifth of each chord in the left. For guitar or ukulele, strum the chord symbols under a sung or played melody. For a band, hand the melody to one player and the chords to the others.

Bars 1–4 for piano. The left hand plays C and G, then F and C twice, then G and D. Check each pair: the root and the fifth of the chord symbol above it.
Before you finish, add a tempo, such as a quarter note equals 100, and one or two dynamics, like soft for A and louder for B. They cost nothing and tell another player what you meant.

The whole piece, A B A: bars 1–8 (A, soft), bars 9–12 (B, louder) and bars 13–20 (A again). Check your own arrangement against it.
Then get it out of your head. Enter the notes into a notation program, or record yourself playing it and keep the file. In a notation program, enter the melody first, add chord symbols next and play it back to check the bars add up. On paper, count each bar aloud as you write it. Do both once, because they teach different things: notation shows you wrong notes and uneven bars, and a recording shows you what the piece sounds like to someone else.
Constraint: one tempo mark, two dynamics, and nothing else: no extra parts until the plain version plays from start to finish. For a first piece built on a different constraint, try writing a two-voice canon.
When you get stuck
Stuck usually means too many choices. Shrink them:
- Fewer notes. Write the phrase with five notes only, then add a sixth.
- Fewer chords. Use I and V for the whole period, then add IV.
- Borrow a skeleton. Keep the rhythm of a tune you like and change every pitch.
- Change the instrument. Sing the line, or play it on a different instrument, and the next note often shows up.
If a bar sounds wrong, play it three times before changing it. Sometimes the problem is a note, and sometimes it is the chord under it; changing one at a time tells you which.
How to get feedback
Play the piece for one person and ask three things: where did you want it to stop, where did you get bored and which part did you hum afterward? Their answers tell you more than “it’s nice.” Record yourself, leave the file for a day and listen again with fresh ears. A teacher can add what a friend cannot: a Tissimo teacher can check your harmony, point out where a phrase ends too early and suggest the next constraint to try. You can find a teacher and book a lesson when you want a second set of ears.
A four-week plan

Twenty to thirty minutes a session, four or five sessions a week. If a week runs long, move on anyway; finishing beats perfecting.
- Week 1: capture and motif. Record ten scraps, write the two best as notes, and try repeat, sequence and inversion on your favorite.
- Week 2: phrase and period. Write the rhythm first, finish a four-bar phrase, then write the answer.
- Week 3: harmony and form. Choose chords from I, IV, V and vi, write a contrasting B and bring A back.
- Week 4: arrange and share. Add a left hand or backing track, enter it in notation or record it, and play it for one listener.
Free worksheets for this lesson
- Motif and sequence — the motif and how to repeat, move and change it
- Find the motif and the sequence — label how the motif returns in four tunes
- Phrase and period — question and answer phrases, with an original eight-bar example
- Cadences — how phrases end, with audio
- The primary chords: I, IV and V — the three-chord family and how songs use it
- Choosing chords for a melody — pick chords by strong-beat notes and plan the cadences first
- Harmonize a melody — choose I, IV or V7 for each bar
- Musical form — letters for sections, and four forms
- Binary, rounded binary and ternary — how to tell the forms apart
- Label the form — letter the parts of real pieces
Sources
Read this article online: https://tissimo.co/articles/how-to-start-composing-music-a-beginners-path

Comments