
What Is a Concerto? Soloist, Orchestra and the Cadenza
A concerto is a piece in which one player, or a small group of players, stands out against a full orchestra. Sometimes the two sides take turns, sometimes they pull against each other, and sometimes they play together. That push and pull is the whole idea, and it is what the Italian word already says: concerto can mean an accord or a gathering, and it comes from a Latin verb, concertare, that can also mean a contest. Three hundred years of composers have written music about both meanings at once. This guide follows the concerto from Corelli to Rachmaninoff, shows you how its parts work with four original examples, and ends with a short plan for listening to one.
Soloist and orchestra: who does what
Compare it with a symphony, which is written for the orchestra alone. In a concerto the soloist is the lead voice: the player who gets the fast passages, the long melodic lines and, as you will see, the moment when everyone else falls silent. The orchestra is more than an accompanist, though. It states themes, answers the soloist and sometimes plays an entire section without them.
Orchestras also differ by period. Corelli's Op. 6 needs only strings and continuo; Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 20, K. 466, adds a flute, two oboes, two bassoons, two horns, two trumpets and timpani; his No. 23, K. 488, trades the oboes for two clarinets and drops the trumpets and drums. Our guide to the instruments of the orchestra shows who sits where in a larger group.
The Baroque concerto grosso: a small group against the orchestra
The concerto grosso took shape first, in the late seventeenth century. A small group of soloists, the concertino, passes the music back and forth with the full orchestra, the ripieno. Arcangelo Corelli wrote its best-known examples. His twelve concerti grossi, Op. 6, composed over many years up to 1712, were published in Amsterdam in 1714, the year after his death, and they set a concertino of two violins and a cello against a string orchestra with continuo.

The two Baroque plans. In a concerto grosso a trio of soloists answers the orchestra; in a solo concerto one player does.
Hold on to the word continuo: it names the keyboard and bass-instrument team that played the chords underneath almost all Baroque music (our guide to Roman numeral analysis and figured bass shows how players read them). Our Periods of Music History sheet explains it in a line, next to the other sounds that mark the Baroque: steady driving rhythm, ornaments, and loud and soft that change in blocks.
The solo concerto and the ritornello
Next to the concerto grosso grew the solo concerto, with one star. Giuseppe Torelli wrote many violin concertos whose fast movements put a recurring orchestral passage between two long solo passages, and Antonio Vivaldi, who wrote hundreds of concertos, standardized the scheme. That recurring passage is the ritornello, Italian for "little return." Between its appearances the soloist plays episodes: new, showier music, often in running notes.
Here is an original ritornello in A minor, written to show the habits of the type. It opens with a repeated-note head, repeats the shape a step lower, falls toward the dominant and lands at home.

An original ritornello. Bar 1: an A minor arpeggio. Bar 2: the same shape on G. Bar 3: F E D C, then B and G♯. Bar 4: A.
In this example the soloist keeps the frame of the ritornello's harmony and changes the surface. The ritornello's chords are Am, G, Dm, E, Am; the sixteenths below keep only its two pillars (A minor, then E7, the dominant seventh, then A minor again) and turn them into arpeggios a violinist can play at speed. In a real movement the episodes also carry the music to new keys.

An original solo episode. Bar 1: A C E C twice, then G♯ B D B twice (E7 without its root). Bar 2: A minor again, landing on A.
The movement is built by alternating the two. Vivaldi's convention is that the first and last ritornellos are in the home key and at least one in between is in the dominant, here E minor. That change of key is a modulation.

The same head in two keys. Bar 1: A minor. Bar 2: E minor, the dominant key.
Put the pieces in order and you get a map you can hold in your head while you listen.

A typical shape for a fast Baroque solo-concerto movement. The number of returns varies from piece to piece.
Vivaldi's best-known concertos use this plan. His Op. 3, L'estro armonico, was published in Amsterdam in 1711, and in 1725 came another Amsterdam collection, Op. 8, that contained The Four Seasons. Solo concertos of this kind usually run fast, slow, fast: the three-movement pattern that became a standard from the early eighteenth century.
Try it at the keyboard
You can feel the ritornello idea with the three figures above. Play the four bars of the ritornello, slowly, with the right hand, or with both hands an octave apart, until you can sing the head from memory. Then play the episode at a pace where every sixteenth is even. Last, try moving the head to E minor as in the third figure and hear how it sounds like the same tune in a new room. If you would like to write your own, keep the rule: the orchestra states the idea, the soloist answers with something new and showier, and the idea comes back.
Bach and the first keyboard concertos
Johann Sebastian Bach learned from Vivaldi's printed concertos: in Weimar in the 1710s he arranged five of the L'estro armonico concertos for harpsichord or organ, and later, in Leipzig, a sixth for four harpsichords and strings. He also wrote concertos of his own. The six Brandenburg Concertos, BWV 1046–1051, were compiled and sent to the Margrave of Brandenburg with a dedication dated 24 March 1721. In the fifth, the harpsichord, which usually sits in the background as continuo, takes a starring role next to a flute and a violin, and it plays an extended cadenza that Bach wrote out. The harpsichord part is presumed to have been written for a new harpsichord by Michael Mietke that Bach collected and paid for in Berlin in 1719 for his employer's court. Scholars see this concerto as the starting point of the solo keyboard concerto: it is the first concerto to give a keyboard instrument a solo part.
The Classical concerto: three movements and a double exposition
By the time Mozart took up the form, the plan was settled. Fast, slow, fast: a first movement, a slow movement, and a lively finale, often a rondo. Mozart wrote 21 original concertos for one piano and orchestra, from K. 175 in December 1773 to K. 595 in January 1791, and he was the soloist at the first performance of the Piano Concerto No. 20 in D minor, K. 466, at the Mehlgrube concert hall in Vienna on 11 February 1785.
The biggest change from the Baroque is in the first movement, which follows sonata form. If you have read our guide to binary, ternary, rondo and sonata form, you know that a sonata movement begins with an exposition that presents two themes in two keys. In a concerto the exposition is split in two: a tutti exposition for the orchestra and then a solo exposition for the soloist. This is the double exposition.

A Classical first movement. The cadenza comes toward the end of the recapitulation, and the orchestra closes.
Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 23 in A, K. 488, finished on 2 March 1786, shows it clearly. The orchestra plays the first exposition, which is tonally static. The piano joins for the second exposition, which modulates and brings in a third theme the orchestra had not played. The Sonata form worksheet shows the underlying plan, two themes, two keys and one homecoming, with Mozart's piano sonata K. 545 as an example, and the Musical form sheet gives you the rondo letters (A B A C A) you will hear in many concerto finales.
Movement by movement: K. 488
Mozart's K. 488 gives you the whole fast–slow–fast plan in a single piece. The first movement is an Allegro in A major, with the double exposition described above. The second is an Adagio in F♯ minor, in 6/8 time, where the mood turns inward. The Adagio is in ternary form and opens with the piano alone in a siciliano rhythm; it is the only movement by Mozart in F♯ minor. The finale is an Allegro assai in A major, alla breve, in sonata-rondo form: a returning main tune with contrasting episodes. It recalls the ritornello, except that the refrain comes back in the home key.
The cadenza: the soloist alone
As the Wikipedia article on the cadenza puts it, a cadenza is "an improvised or written-out ornamental passage played or sung by a soloist(s), usually in a 'free' rhythmic style, and often allowing virtuosic display." The word is Italian for "cadence," which is why the passage ends on one (see our guide to cadences). In a concerto it normally comes near the end of the first movement, though it can sit anywhere. The recipe is simple. The orchestra stops, usually on a I⁶₄ chord with a fermata in all parts. The soloist plays alone and as freely as the player wishes. At the end comes a trill, usually on the supertonic, and the orchestra returns to finish the movement.

An original cadenza sketch in C major. Bar 1: C/G with a fermata. Bar 2: arpeggios over G7 (played freely). Bar 3: a trill on D.
Mozart's own cadenzas survive for most of his concertos, but none is known for K. 466. Other composers supplied them, among them Brahms, Clara Schumann, Hummel, Busoni and Beethoven, and Beethoven's set (WoO 58), for the first and third movements, is the most often performed. So the same Mozart concerto can sound different from one soloist to the next, depending on whose cadenza is played.
The Romantic concerto: virtuosity and written-out cadenzas
In the nineteenth century the concerto became a vehicle for virtuosic display. Concertos also grew: a Baroque concerto lasted about ten minutes, and Beethoven's about half an hour or more. Among the Romantic composers who wrote concertos were Paganini, Chopin, Schumann, Brahms and Tchaikovsky. Beethoven, who bridges the two periods (our Periods sheet says he "starts Classical and ends Romantic"), shows the change. His "Emperor" Concerto (Piano Concerto No. 5, composed in 1809, premiered 28 November 1811 in Leipzig with Friedrich Schneider as the soloist) opens with cadenza-like flourishes for the piano between orchestral chords. Later in the first movement Beethoven writes out the cadenza and tells the soloist not to add one of their own. After this piece, composers increasingly wrote their own cadenzas instead of leaving them to the performer. The first movement runs orchestral exposition, solo exposition, development, recapitulation, written cadenza and coda, so the plan is the double exposition of Mozart with the cadenza taken out of the player's hands. Mendelssohn took the idea on in his Violin Concerto in E minor, Op. 64: he first planned it in 1838, dated the score 16 September 1844, and it was premiered on 13 March 1845 in Leipzig with Ferdinand David as the soloist. Mendelssohn moved the written-out cadenza to the end of the development, before the recapitulation, and let the soloist enter almost at once, with no long orchestral introduction.
Later in the century Brahms wrote a Double Concerto for violin and cello with orchestra, so the idea of more than one soloist never went away. And Rachmaninoff composed his Piano Concerto No. 2 between June 1900 and April 1901. It begins with the solo piano alone, tolling in chromatic, bell-like chords that build tension until the violins, violas and first clarinet bring in the main theme. The complete work was premiered in Moscow on 9 November 1901 (27 October on the Russian calendar of the time).

Eight dates in the concerto story. Each is a composition, publication, dedication or performance, as the label says.
Rachmaninoff's concerto premiered just after the usual 1900 end date for the Romantic period on our Periods of Music History sheet, which says plainly that period dates are approximate: styles change gradually, not on New Year's Day.

The three eras side by side. Dates are approximate and styles overlap.
If you want the bigger picture, our guide to the eras of classical music puts the Baroque, Classical and Romantic periods on one timeline.
How to listen to a concerto
You do not need a score. Put on a recording and use the questions that fit its period. Three good first targets: the first movement of Vivaldi's "Spring" (Op. 8 No. 1), where the ritornello keeps returning; the first movement of Mozart's K. 488, with its double exposition and a cadenza before the coda; and the first movement of Mendelssohn's Op. 64, where the soloist enters almost at once and the written cadenza comes before the recapitulation.

A listening plan. Not every step applies to every period.
- Find the soloist. Who is playing alone, and when does the orchestra take over?
- Hear the return. In a fast Baroque movement, listen for the orchestra's theme coming back, once, twice, three times.
- Count the expositions. In a Classical first movement, does the orchestra play its themes before the soloist enters?
- Wait for the pause. The orchestra stops, often on a held chord. The cadenza has begun.
- Listen for the trill. In a Classical concerto, a trill usually ends the cadenza before the orchestra comes back.
Try the same plan on a Baroque, a Classical and a Romantic example, and you will begin to hear the differences without needing the dates.
Free worksheets for this lesson
- The Periods of Music History — a timeline of composers' lifetimes and what each period sounds like, with a "period detective" listening task
- Sonata form — the exposition, development and recapitulation plan, with theme 2 away and at home in Mozart's K. 545
- Musical form — the letters A, A′, B and C, and four forms you will meet: binary, ternary, rondo, and theme and variations
Where to go next
If a concerto makes you want to play one, the first step is the same as for any solo: a steady pulse, a clear idea of the form, and someone who can listen to you. A Tissimo music teacher can work through a concerto movement with you in a live lesson, from the solo part's phrasing to how you fit in with the orchestra's lines. You can book a lesson when you are ready.
Sources
- Concerto — Wikipedia
- Ritornello — Wikipedia
- Concerto grosso — Wikipedia
- 12 Concerti grossi, Op. 6 (Corelli) — IMSLP
- L'estro armonico — Wikipedia
- Il cimento dell'armonia e dell'inventione, Op. 8 (Vivaldi) — IMSLP
- Brandenburg Concertos — Wikipedia
- Piano concertos by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart — Wikipedia
- Piano Concerto No. 20 (Mozart) — Wikipedia
- Piano Concerto No. 23 (Mozart) — Wikipedia
- Piano Concerto No. 23 in A major, K. 488 (Mozart) — IMSLP
- Cadenza — Wikipedia
- Piano Concerto No. 5 (Beethoven) — Wikipedia
- Violin Concerto (Mendelssohn) — Wikipedia
- Piano Concerto No. 2 (Rachmaninoff) — Wikipedia
Read this article online: https://tissimo.co/articles/what-is-a-concerto-soloist-and-orchestra-explained

Comments