Skip to main content
Back
Cover image for the Minimalism in Music Explained: Repetition, Process and Phasing blog article

Minimalism in Music Explained: Repetition, Process and Phasing

Minimalism in music is not quiet or simple so much as exposed. A few notes repeat, and something small changes slowly enough that you can watch it happen. This article covers where the style came from in 1960s America, the four techniques that matter most (repetition, additive and subtractive process, phasing and slow harmonic change), how to listen to a piece that seems to go nowhere, and where the sound ended up in film and rock. Midway through there is an original exercise for two players that lets you hear phasing yourself.

Where minimalism came from

The word "minimal" was applied to music only after the music existed, and sources disagree on who first did it. The critic and composer Michael Nyman is thought to have used it first, in 1968, while Philip Glass believes the critic Tom Johnson coined it. What the word came to name was a group of American composers (La Monte Young, Terry Riley, Steve Reich and Glass, among others) who built music from deliberately limited material: repeated patterns, steady pulses, long drones and consonant harmony. Glass himself never liked the label and preferred to call his work "music with repetitive structures."

Of the four, Young came first. His Trio for Strings (1958) is built from sustained tones, and has been called an "origin point for minimalism." His Composition 1960 #7 is a B and an F♯ with the instruction "to be held for a long time." Later he and the artist Marian Zazeela developed the Dream House, a continuous sound and light environment, and in 1964 he began his long-running piano work The Well-Tuned Piano. Notice what he took away: tunes, development, drama. What was left was duration.

Timeline of ten works on nine dates from 1958 to 1982: Young's Trio for Strings; Riley's In C; Reich's It's Gonna Rain, Come Out, Piano Phase, Clapping Music and Music for 18 Musicians; Glass's 1+1 and Einstein on the Beach; and the Koyaanisqatsi score

Selected works named in this article. Dates are the years given by the sources listed at the end.

In C: one page, fifty-three patterns

Terry Riley's In C was composed in March 1964 and first performed on November 4, 1964, at the San Francisco Tape Music Center. Steve Reich was in the first ensemble, as were Pauline Oliveros and Morton Subotnick. The whole score is 53 short patterns that fit on a single page. The rules are few:

  • The 53 patterns are played in order.
  • Each player decides how many times to repeat a pattern before moving on.
  • There is no required tempo, and players are asked to listen closely to one another.

During house concerts that fall Reich suggested a steady eighth-note pulse to hold the group together, and Riley agreed. At the premiere Jeanie Brechan played that pulse on the top two C's of a piano, and David Behrman's liner notes for the 1968 Columbia recording describe it the same way. Because each player decides when to move on, no two performances come out quite alike. Riley estimates a performance at 45 to 90 minutes; the 1968 recording runs about 43 minutes. Scholars such as Keith Potter note that In C has often been seen as the beginning of musical minimalism, though Young's earlier work shows that the beginning was not a single event.

For a taste of how this works at the keyboard, The Ostinato is a worksheet on one repeating pattern, C–G–A–G in the left hand, over which the right hand wanders. It is not In C, but it trains the same skill: a stubborn loop holding steady while everything else is free to move.

Repetition: the raw material

Everything else builds on repetition. The standard description of minimal music lists repetitive patterns or pulses, steady drones, consonant harmony and the reiteration of phrases or smaller units. Repetition changes how you hear. The first time a cell plays you hear a melody; the twentieth time you hear its accents, its rests, the way the last note leans back into the first. A tune that would be forgotten after one hearing becomes a landscape you can walk around in.

That is also why many minimalist pieces are long. You cannot rush the effect. If you are a player, the same rule applies at the instrument: repeat a pattern until it is automatic, then listen to it as if someone else were playing.

Reich and phasing

Reich's discovery came from tape. In 1964 he recorded a Pentecostal preacher, Brother Walter, in San Francisco's Union Square. In 1965 he made a loop of a phrase from that recording and ran two copies on two ordinary Wollensak tape recorders. He had meant to set the two copies in a fixed relationship, one half a loop behind the other. Instead one drifted ahead of the other, because of tiny differences in the machines, the loop lengths and the playback speed, and the sound turned into a shifting, echoing texture. The result was It's Gonna Rain (1965); Come Out (1966) applied the same method to another recorded voice.

Schematic of two rows of evenly spaced marks, the second row spaced slightly closer, drifting from alignment

Phasing with tape in schematic form: the same loop runs a hair faster on one machine, so the two copies slowly pull apart. Spacing is exaggerated.

Reich then took the idea to live musicians. Piano Phase (1967) is for two pianists (or one pianist and tape). Both play the same twelve-note figure, built from five pitches: E F♯ B C♯ D F♯ E C♯ B F♯ D C♯. One pianist then begins to play slightly faster than the other, and the two drift apart until the two parts lock one note apart. They stay there for a while, then slip again, and so on until they come full circle into unison. A performance typically lasts 15 to 20 minutes. Clapping Music (1972) uses a variation with hands alone: one performer claps a 12-pulse pattern in 12/8 throughout, while the other, every eight or twelve bars, jumps ahead by one eighth note by skipping a note or rest.

Phasing produces something the score never contains. In his 1968 essay "Music as a Gradual Process," Reich wrote that he wanted a process that is audible all the way through, and that "listening to it resembles watching the minute hand on a watch." He also described the "unintended, psycho-acoustic by-products" of a process, including "submelodies heard within repeated melodic patterns." Those are the new tunes you start to hear when two copies of one pattern overlap.

Phasing is a cousin of polyrhythm: both put two patterns against each other at once. If that sounds interesting, Polyrhythms Explained: Three Against Two and Beyond is a good next read, and the Polyrhythms worksheet lets you tap 3 against 2 with the "nice cup of tea" phrase. Where polyrhythm holds two slicings of a beat side by side, phasing makes the offset between two identical patterns change over time.

Try it: a phasing exercise for two players

This exercise is original. It is not Reich's pattern, but it uses the method of Clapping Music: jump ahead one whole eighth note at a time. You need two players, and any pitched instrument works.

First learn the loop. It is six eighth notes in 6/8 and uses E4, G4, A4 and C5. Say the counts 1 to 6 out loud. Play it at a steady tempo, around 100 eighth notes per minute, until you do not have to think.

One bar in 6/8 of six eighth notes E G A C A G, counted 1 to 6, written twice

The loop for both players: E4, G4, A4, C5, A4, G4, with the counts written below.

Then play it together for eight loops. After that, Player 2 starts the next loop one eighth note ahead: instead of E, Player 2's first note is G, and the rest of the pattern follows in order. To make the slip, Player 2 simply leaves out one note: play G A C A G, then carry on from E without a break. That one skipped eighth is the whole shift. Hold that alignment for eight loops, then slip ahead again the same way. Fully notated, there are six alignments:

Two staves, six bars in 6/8: Player 1 repeats E G A C A G while Player 2 plays the same loop starting one eighth further along in each bar

Player 2 is 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, then 5 eighth notes ahead of Player 1. Another slip would bring Player 2 around to unison.

What do you hear? The grid below shows what is happening in plain terms: for each alignment, which of the six slots have the same pitch in both parts.

Grid of six rows showing Player 2's loop at each shift against Player 1's loop, with same-pitch slots highlighted

At 0 eighths ahead all six slots match; at 2 and 4, two slots match; at 1, 3 and 5, none do.

The most distinctive sound is the halfway point, 3 eighths ahead, where the pairs mirror each other: Player 1's E against Player 2's C in the first slot, C against E in the fourth, and G and A trading places in the other four. The moment that needs the most care is the slip itself. Even a tiny timing error is easy to hear against the other part, so go slowly. Because every slip is a clean jump of one whole eighth, a note that lands off the grid is simply a mistake, so count aloud. Once the jumps are easy, try the harder Piano Phase way: Player 2 speeds up very slightly until landing one note ahead, then settles. If you only have yourself, play the loop with your right hand and let your left hand play Player 2's part an octave lower, or loop a recording of the pattern and play against it. The skill here is the same one as in Keep the Pulse Through Silence: hold a steady beat whatever else is happening.

Additive and subtractive process

Glass took a different route. He studied with Nadia Boulanger in Paris from 1964 to 1966, and in 1965 and 1966 he worked on the film score for Chappaqua with Ravi Shankar and Alla Rakha. Glass came away hearing their approach to rhythm as additive: built by counting and grouping small units rather than dividing a bar. His additive method is generally traced to that experience. Beginning with 1+1 in 1968, he wrote a series of works with an additive process, in which a pattern repeats and one note is added at a time (1, 1 2, 1 2 3, 1 2 3 4).

Eight bars of eighth notes, four cells each written twice: E G (2/8), E G A (3/8), E G A G (4/8), E G A G E (5/8)

An original example of the process: the bar is played twice, then one note is added at the end. The eighth note never changes; the length of the cell does.

Run the steps in the opposite order and the same material becomes subtractive. Sources describe Glass's process as adding or subtracting a note, so the pattern can grow or shrink.

Eight bars of eighth notes, four cells each written twice: E G A G E (5/8), E G A G (4/8), E G A (3/8), E G (2/8)

The same notes, losing the last one every two bars.

Notice how this differs from the "motif and sequence" development you hear in classical music. A motif is repeated, moved to a new pitch or changed in shape to carry a melody forward (see What Is a Motif? and the Motif and sequence worksheet). In an additive process the notes remain identical and only the count changes. The result feels like a machine slowly adding gears.

Glass's opera Einstein on the Beach, created with the director Robert Wilson, was first performed at the Festival d'Avignon in the summer of 1976.

Slow change in harmony and texture

The last technique is the least obvious. When the harmony changes rarely, each change becomes an event. Slow change is easiest to appreciate with a steady pulse underneath, because the pulse tells you how long the harmony has stayed put. Reich's Music for 18 Musicians (premiered April 24, 1976) is built on a cycle of eleven chords. Each chord gets its own long section, so a single harmony can hold for minutes while the pulse runs on. If you want to hear harmonic rhythm, Hear When the Chord Changes: Harmonic Rhythm by Ear explains how, and the worksheet Many Notes, Fewer Chord Changes has audio examples where many notes sound but the chord changes only a few times.

Texture can change just as slowly. Here a pattern stays almost fixed and only one note is swapped per bar:

Four bars of eight eighth notes; bar 1 is E G A G E G A G, then notes 4, 8 and 2 are replaced in turn and labeled new

Slow change by substitution, an original example. Bar 2: note 4 becomes C. Bar 3: note 8 becomes C. Bar 4: note 2 becomes A.

Four cards summarizing repetition, additive and subtractive process, phasing and slow change

The four techniques at a glance. Real pieces often combine them.

How to listen

Minimalism asks for a different kind of attention. Nothing is hidden, so you listen to the details. Give a piece three or four minutes before you decide anything, then try these steps in order:

  1. Find the pulse and tap it.
  2. Find the cell, the smallest repeating pattern you can hum.
  3. Wait for the first change, and notice when you realize it has happened.
  4. Listen for patterns you did not hear at the start, the by-products of the overlap.
Four step cards: find the pulse, find the cell, spot the change, hear what is not written

A short listening guide for any process piece.

Try Piano Phase. Near the start both pianos play the twelve-note figure in unison. Listen for the blur as one pianist edges ahead, then the click when the two lock one note apart and new submelodies appear. For In C, listen for the steady high-C pulse and how the texture thickens as players reach new patterns.

Reich's minute-hand comparison is the right mindset. At first the hand seems still; stay with it a little while and you can perceive it moving.

Where it went: film and rock

Film has proved a natural fit. Godfrey Reggio's non-narrative documentary Koyaanisqatsi (1982) has a score by Glass, performed by the Philip Glass Ensemble and conducted by Michael Riesman. A piece cut from the film, "Façades," was released on Glass's 1982 album Glassworks. Glass has since earned three Academy Award nominations for Best Original Score: Kundun (1997), The Hours (2002) and Notes on a Scandal (2006). The Truman Show (1998) also draws on his music.

Beyond film, Brian Eno has cited It's Gonna Rain as his first experience of minimalism and of what became ambient music. In rock, the clearest named link is The Who's "Baba O'Riley," the opening track of Who's Next (1971). Pete Townshend named it for two inspirations, Meher Baba and Terry Riley, and the pulsing opening comes from a Lowrey organ using its marimba-repeat feature.

Free worksheets for this lesson

Keep going

Minimalism teaches patience, and the best way to feel it is to play it. A Tissimo piano teacher can coach you through a phasing exercise in a live lesson and tell you where your steady pulse slips. You can book a lesson when you want that kind of check.

Sources

Read this article online: https://tissimo.co/articles/minimalism-in-music-explained-reich-glass-riley

Was this useful?
Dislike buttonLike button
Thank you for your feedback imageThanks for your feedback

Comments