Skip to main content
Back
Cover image for the How to Harmonize a Melody: Choosing Chords Step by Step blog article

How to Harmonize a Melody: Choosing Chords Step by Step

You have a tune, maybe your own or a folk song, and you want chords under it. In a major key, choosing them follows a short, repeatable process. This guide walks through it in eight steps with two original eight-bar melodies, in C major and G major, bar by bar.

What harmonizing a melody means

To harmonize a melody is to choose the chords that sound underneath it. Tissimo's handout Choosing chords for a melody puts the whole job in one sentence: "Three questions do the work: which chords own the important notes, how often to change, and where each phrase ends."

A chord "owns" a note when that note is one of its chord tones. The second question is about time; the third, phrase endings, decides some chords before any others. And harmonizing rarely has a single right answer: when the strong-beat notes fit two chords, the hint on Harmonize a melody 2 says "both answers are right: play each and choose."

Step 1: Find the key and the chords that live in it

Read the key signature, then look at the last note: many simple melodies in a major key end on the tonic. How to Find the Key of a Song covers the other clues.

Next, build a chord on every note of the scale by stacking thirds. In any major key the qualities follow one order: major, minor, minor, major, major, minor, diminished. In Roman numerals that is I, ii, iii, IV, V, vi, vii°: capitals for major, lower case for minor, a small circle for diminished. The chords of a key shows the recipe, and Name the chords of the key drills it.

Start with the primary chords, I, IV and V; The primary chords: I, IV & V says that "together they can harmonize almost anything." Then add two minor chords, ii and vi. The Choosing chords handout marks iii and vii° as "rarely used to harmonize," and this guide sets them aside too.

Grid of seven scale degrees against five chords I, ii, IV, V and vi in C major and G major; cyan cells show which chords contain each degree: degree 1 in I, IV, vi; 2 in ii, V; 3 in I, vi; 4 in ii, IV (and V7); 5 in I, V; 6 in ii, IV, vi; 7 in V only

Which of the five common chords contain each note of the key. Degree 7, the leading tone, belongs only to V among these five.

Every note of a major key belongs to three of its seven chords; with iii and vii° left out, each note has one to three owners. This guide stays in major keys; for a tune in a minor key, start from The chords of a minor key.

Step 2: Mark the notes on beats 1 and 3

In 4/4 time, beats 1 and 3 are the strong beats, and both melodies in this guide are in 4/4. In 3/4 only beat 1 is strong, so start with one chord a bar; Time Signatures Explained covers the other meters. The worksheets Harmonize a melody and Harmonize a melody 2 give the rule this guide uses: the chord must contain the melody notes on the strong beats. Music theorist Daniel Stevens describes it from the listener's side: "Melodic tones on strong beats that don't fit the prior harmony often cause the harmony to sound like it needs to change."

Here is the first melody. Count it, then name every note that falls on beat 1 or beat 3.

Eight-bar melody in C major, 4/4, treble clef: bar 1 E F E G, bar 2 A G F A, bar 3 G A as half notes, bar 4 B C then half-note D, bar 5 E D C B, bar 6 A G F A, bar 7 G A B D, bar 8 whole-note C; beat numbers under every note and letter names under the notes on beats 1 and 3

Melody 1, an original tune in C major. The strong-beat notes are E E, A F, G A, B D, E C, A F, G B and C.

One exception: a melody can lean on a non-chord tone right on the beat. Stevens points out that "Happy Birthday" places an upper neighbor on the song's downbeat. If the chord a strong-beat note asks for breaks your cadence plan or clashes with the notes around it, and that note steps straight into a tone of the chord you wanted, treat it as a visitor and let the next note choose.

Step 3: List the chords that own each strong beat

Under every strong-beat note, write the chords from the grid that contain it. A chord that lasts the whole bar has to appear under both strong beats.

Melody 1 with every note on beats 1 and 3 labeled with its possible chords: E gets I and vi, A gets ii, IV and vi, F gets ii and IV, G gets I and V, B gets V, D gets ii and V, C gets I, IV and vi

Possible chords under each strong beat of Melody 1. In bar 3, G and A share no chord, so the harmony must change on beat 3.

Bars 1 (E, E) and 5 (E, C) point to I or vi; bar 2 (A, F) to IV or ii; bars 4 (B, D) and 7 (G, B) allow only V. Bar 6 (A, F) matches bar 2, and bar 8 (C) could be I, IV or vi; the ending makes it I. In bar 3, G (I or V) and A (ii, IV or vi) share no chord, so bar 3 needs two.

Step 4: Plan the cadences first

A cadence is the harmonic punctuation at the end of a phrase. The Cadences handout names three: the authentic cadence, V(7) → I, "a full stop"; the plagal cadence, IV → I, the "A-men"; and the half cadence, ending on V, "a comma."

Melody 1 has two four-bar phrases. Bar 4 pauses on a half note, and its strong-beat notes, B and D, fit only V; bar 8 ends on the tonic, so bar 4 gets a half cadence and bars 7–8 an authentic cadence (V7 is V with one more third on top, G–B–D–F; Step 7 says when to choose it). Stevens's advice is "Begin at the end," and the Choosing chords handout agrees: "Plan the cadences first, fill the middle with I, IV and V, then add color."

Melody 1 with only the cadence chords written in: V under bar 4 labeled half cadence, V7 under bar 7 and I under bar 8 labeled authentic cadence

The cadence plan. Bar 4 can only be V, so the first phrase ends on a half cadence; bars 7 and 8 close with V7 → I.

At a half cadence, use plain V: Open Music Theory notes that the V there "is almost invariably a triad." At the final cadence, it advises approaching the last tonic note by step, preferably from degree 2 (D to C here); a V → I with the melody arriving on the tonic is a perfect authentic cadence. Cadences Explained covers all four common cadence types; Identify the cadences has eight phrases to label.

Step 5: Choose a harmonic rhythm

Harmonic rhythm is how long each chord lasts, or, in the Choosing chords handout's words, "how often the chords change." Stevens recommends "as few harmonies as possible, changing only when the melody (or your ear) requires it." For Melody 1 that means one chord a bar, two in bar 3. Fill the middle with I, IV and V:

Melody 1 harmonized on a grand staff with I, IV and V(7): left-hand block chords C, F, C then F, G, C, F, G7, C with Roman numerals under the bass staff and chord symbols above the melody

First pass: I | IV | I IV | V || I | IV | V7 | I. Every strong-beat note sits in the chord under it.

Play it with block chords in the left hand and the tune in the right.

The Comprehensive Musicianship textbook notes that harmonic rhythm often speeds up or slows down at cadence points; bar 3 of Melody 1 already does it, and the second melody does it before both cadences. To train your ear, Many Notes, Fewer Chord Changes maps three short tracks on a beat-by-beat timeline: listen and say "change" only when the harmony changes, not on every new note. Hear When the Chord Changes is the matching article.

Step 6: Let the in-between notes be visitors

Notes on beats 2 and 4 that are not in the chord are non-chord tones, and in simple tunes most of them step in and step out. The handout Non-chord tones calls them "short visitors that add motion and spice." Two kinds cover most simple tunes:

  • Passing tone (P): walks by step between two chord tones, in one direction (E–F–G, or A–G–F).
  • Neighbor tone (N): steps away from a chord tone and straight back to the same note (E–F–E).
Melody 1 with chord symbols C, F, C F, G, C, F, G7, C above and labels under the visitors: N under the F in bar 1, P under the G in bar 2, the C in bar 4, the D and B in bar 5, the G in bar 6 and the A in bar 7

The seven visitors in Melody 1: one neighbor tone and six passing tones, all on beat 2 or 4, all moving by step.

Give each visitor its own chord and the harmony changes on almost every note, so leave them alone. Visitors can also fall on the beat (the Puget Sound textbook calls these accented), as in Step 2's exception. For suspensions, appoggiaturas and the rest, read Non-Chord Tones Explained, then practice with Label the non-chord tones.

Step 7: Add color with ii, vi and V7

I, IV and V work, but they can sound plain. The Choosing chords handout gives the next move: "vi can stand in for I and ii for IV, because each shares two notes with it, and ii can lead into V." C–E–G and A–C–E share two notes, as do F–A–C and D–F–A.

Open Music Theory groups I and vi as tonic chords, IV and ii as subdominant (pre-dominant) and V as dominant; Harmonic Function Explained goes deeper. The Puget Sound textbook adds that IV and ii "tend to progress to chords of dominant function," so ii works well right before V.

Melody 1 harmonized with color chords on a grand staff: C, F, C then Dm/F, G, C then Am, Dm/F, G7, C, with Roman numerals I, IV, I ii6, V, I vi, ii6, V7, I under the bass

Second pass: ii6 replaces the IV in bar 3 and leads into the half cadence; vi joins I in bar 5; ii6 takes bar 6 before V7 → I.

Every strong-beat note still fits. The 6 in ii6 means first inversion: the chord's 3rd, F, is the bass note (Dm/F); Step 8 shows why. The second phrase, I–vi–ii6–V7–I, is a tonic, pre-dominant, dominant, tonic chain of the kind the Puget Sound textbook describes. The dominant 7th explains V7's pull home. The hint on Harmonize a melody 2 adds: "write V7 when the melody's 7th can't be a visitor (it is on a strong beat, or doesn't step in and out)."

Step 8: Check the bass line

Before you finish, play just the outer voices: melody and bass. Strict classical part writing avoids two faults between any pair of voices: parallel fifths and parallel octaves, where both voices move the same way and stay a fifth (or an octave) apart. Left-hand block chords are a sketch, not strict part writing (root-position triads moved side by side are parallel by nature), so this guide runs the check where Stevens and Comprehensive Musicianship both start: melody against bass. Stevens notes that you may avoid them "in some styles," while in others "more freedom may be exercised." Here is why bar 3 uses ii6 instead of plain ii:

Bars 3 and 4 of Melody 1 twice on a grand staff. Version A: chords C, Dm, G with the bass C, D, G; the melody G and A are each a 5th above the bass. Version B: chords C, Dm/F, G with the bass C, F, G; the melody A is a 3rd above the bass F

Version A: melody G → A over bass C → D is a pair of parallel fifths. Version B puts F in the bass (ii6), and the fifth becomes a third.

The fix is an inversion: first inversion puts the chord's 3rd in the bass, so Dm becomes Dm/F, or ii6. Inversions smooth the bass, too: in bar 6 plain ii would pass the test, but ii6 lets the bass step F–G into the cadence. Comprehensive Musicianship puts it directly: "When possible, inversions should be used in order to create a smooth bass line." Chord Inversions Explained shows how to build each inversion, and Voice Leading Explained covers the other checks.

Once the chords are settled, Accompaniment patterns shows four left-hand grooves for them.

Worked example: a second melody in G major

Now run all eight steps on a new tune. One sharp and a final G: G major, so every F is F♯. The Primary Chords in G Major shows I, IV and V in this key.

Eight-bar melody in G major with the letter name of every strong-beat note and its possible chords underneath: bar 1 B and G, bar 2 C and E, bar 3 D and C, bar 4 F-sharp and A, bar 5 B and D, bar 6 E and C, bar 7 C and A, bar 8 B and G

Melody 2, steps 1–3: strong-beat notes and their possible chords. In bar 3, D and C share none of the five triads; in bar 7, ii owns both notes, and the cadence still needs V7.

Work through it:

  1. Key and chords. I = G–B–D, ii = A–C–E, IV = C–E–G, V = D–F♯–A, vi = E–G–B.
  2. Strong beats. B G | C E | D C | F♯ A || B D | E C | C A | B G.
  3. Owners. Bar 5 points to I, bars 1 and 8 to I or vi (start and end on I); bars 2 and 6 to IV or ii; bar 4 to V. In bar 3, D (I or V) and C (ii or IV) share none of the five triads. V7 (D–F♯–A–C) holds both, but then the B on beat 2 is neither in the chord nor a stepwise visitor (it leaps down from D), and bar 4 is V already. So bar 3 takes two chords.
  4. Cadences. Bar 4 stops on V (half cadence); bars 7–8 close V7 → I. Bar 7 begins on C, which is in ii and is also the 7th of V7. Putting ii on beat 1 and V7 on beat 3 puts a pre-dominant right before the dominant.
  5. Harmonic rhythm. One chord a bar, two in bars 3 and 7.
  6. Visitors. All seven notes outside their chord are passing tones on beat 2.
  7. Color. ii in bars 3 and 7; IV in bars 2 and 6 (ii would fit there too).
  8. Bass. G | C | G A | D || G | C | A D | G. No parallel fifths or octaves with the melody.
Melody 2 harmonized on a grand staff: chords G, C, G Am, D, G, C, Am D7, G with Roman numerals I, IV, I ii, V, I, IV, ii V7, I under the bass

Melody 2 finished: I | IV | I ii | V || I | IV | ii V7 | I. The harmonic rhythm doubles in bars 3 and 7, just before each cadence.

Side by side, most changes fall where the strong beats demand them or where a cadence approaches; the I–vi in bar 5 of the color version is the one change made purely by choice. Elsewhere one chord holds for the bar.

Timeline of chord blocks for eight bars in three rows: Melody 1 first pass, Melody 1 with color and Melody 2; tonic blocks cyan, dominant navy, others gray; half cadence marked in bar 4 and authentic cadence in bars 7 and 8

Harmonic rhythm at a glance: each block's width is the number of beats the chord lasts.

How to practice harmonizing

Keep the eight steps in front of you until they run by themselves.

Infographic of eight numbered steps in two columns: find the key, mark beats 1 and 3, list the owners, plan the cadences, choose the harmonic rhythm, check the notes in between, add color, check the bass then play

The eight steps on one card. Steps 1–4 find the options and fix the endings; steps 5–8 choose, color and check.

Then work in this order:

  1. Warm up. Play I–IV–V–I and I–vi–ii–V7–I in C and G, left hand alone. The primary chords in C major page shows smooth hand shapes.
  2. Do one exercise. Harmonize a melody uses I, IV and V7 in C and G. Harmonize a melody 2 adds ii and vi. Both print the answers upside down at the foot of the page.
  3. Play every answer. Left-hand chords, right-hand melody. Where the worksheet accepts two answers, play both and pick.
  4. Harmonize your own tune. Do the "Try it" box on Choosing chords for a melody, or a melody of your own; How to Write a Melody shows how to give one clear phrase endings.

The three melodies on Harmonize a melody 2 follow this guide's order: one chord a bar in C, changes on beat 3 in G, and a melody in F where you fill the cadence bars first. Its page also plays each melody alone and with the answer-key chords.

Card showing the live worksheet Harmonize a melody 2, Exercise 57: four step chips, Part 1 in C major with one box per bar and Part 2 in G major with boxes on beat 3 where the chord changes

Parts 1 and 2 of Harmonize a melody 2 (Exercise 57). Part 3, in F major, starts with the cadences.

Free worksheets for this lesson

Keep going

With practice you will see "B on beat 1, so V" without the grid. From there, Roman Numeral Analysis and Figured Bass Explained helps you read the harmonizations in real pieces, and How to Build Piano Chords helps you voice them.

A Tissimo piano teacher can play through your harmonization with you in a live lesson and suggest where a ii, a vi or an inversion would help; book a lesson whenever you are ready.

Sources

Read this article online: https://tissimo.co/articles/how-to-harmonize-a-melody-choosing-chords-step-by-step

Was this useful?
Dislike buttonLike button
Thank you for your feedback imageThanks for your feedback

Comments